Dispute over non-payment at Water Mill gas station Heard on: Eastern Suffolk County Police, Fire, and EMS 00:11 00:00 Shell in Watermill, (number withheld) Montauk Highway. Transcript This transcript is auto-generated from live dispatch audio and may be incomplete or inaccurate. It is not an official report and may change. 00:00 Shell in Watermill, (number withheld) Montauk Highway. 00:05 I've been checking through language line, possible dispute over non-payment. 00:10 Both parties are present. 5/8/2026 01:01 PM Disorderly Conduct Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY 11976 View on map