Dispute at apartment and reports of possible gunfire

2/5/2026 06:08 PM

Family Offense

Wheeler Rd, Central Islip, NY 11722

Officers were sent to an apartment on Wheeler Road in Central Islip for a dispute between tenants. One tenant reported that another tenant was trying to get into their apartment and that they heard what sounded like a gunshot, which they believed was audio played from a phone. Dispatch noted a prior incident at the same location where the current complainant had been seen outside with a rifle, refused to come out at first, then exited the apartment, denied wrongdoing, and was arrested for menacing. The complainant now reports having video of people handling what look like a shotgun and a handgun in a bedroom.